Low-temperature anaerobic wastewater treatment by granulated biomass



up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket, UASB, wastewater, granulated biomass


In this study, long-term operation of up-flow anaerobic sludge blanket (UASB) system treating real municipal wastewater at decreasing temperatures (25, 16, 12, 8.5, 5.5, and 2.5 °C) and variable organic loading rates from 1.0 gCOD·l⁻¹·d⁻¹ up to 15.2 gCOD·l⁻¹·d⁻¹ was investigated over 1025 days. Experiments were performed in two parallel in-house designed laboratory-scale UASB reactors, which were operated continuously with hydraulic retention time of 16.7 h down to 1.1 h. Stable COD removal efficiencies of 50 - 70 % were achieved at 25 °C down to 8.5 °C with loading up to approximately 15.2 gCOD·l-1·d-1. COD removal efficiencies were reduced at temperatures below 8.5 °C, but significant methane formation was observed even at 2.5 °C at reduced loading (up to 5 gCOD·l-1·d-1). More than 90% of COD removed was converted to methane, and the methane yield did not change significantly with respect to temperatures. The overall COD balance closed at above 90% of the inlet COD at all operating temperatures and organic loading rates.

Temperature affected the reactor performances, microbial community structure, and the degradation pathway of organic matter with acetoclastic methanogen played significant roles. Acetate was the primary precursor of methanogenesis pathway at low-temperatures. Microbial communities proved the adaptation ability to very low-temperatures down to 2.5 °C regardless of the operating organic loading rates; psychrotolerant. Additionally, an anaerobic granulated biofilm system at 25 °C and different organic loading rates (1, 3, 8, 10, 15, and 20 gCOD·l-1·d-1) was modelled in AQUASIM 2.1 to predict and simulate biofilm model implementation and assumptions specific to the granules as a fixed biofilm in UASB reactor system in this study. Simulated organic loading rates scenario results showed COD removal efficiencies (62 - 69%) and methane fraction (83 - 88%) in biogas at steady-state conditions decreased with the increasing organic loading rates. All simulations predicted an increased pH profile, from pH 7 in the outer layer to approximately pH 8.3 in the core of granules, under increasing organic loading rates, but the biomass composition and active biofilm regions were not significantly affected by organic loading rate variable.
UASB effluent post-treatment investigations, specifically on dissolved methane and nutrient removal, were performed as supplementary studies. A methanotrophic-cyanobacterial syntrophy was established in the existing oxygenic photogranules to remove dissolved methane. This syntrophy was maintained and propagated in a continuously operated reactor (hydraulic retention time of 12 h), proven by observed biomass yield and dissolved methane removal by approximately 2.4 gVSS·gCH₄⁻¹ and 85%, respectively, with COD balance closed at around 91%. Community analysis suggested methanotrophs and phototrophs syntrophy, and the cross-feeding between photogranules of different community compositions, containing methanotrophic bacteria, phototrophs, and non-methanotrophic methylotrophs.

Nutrient removal from filtered UASB secondary effluent was investigated using several microalgal strains based on a literature review: Chlorella vulgaris, Chlorella sorokiniana, Tetradesmus obliquus, Haematococcus pluvialis, and Microchloropsis salina. Microalgae strain C. sorokiniana presented the ability to grow in wastewater in all the tested culture conditions, suggesting high adaptability and viability of the strain in this specific type of filtered UASB secondary effluent. The results also implied nutrient removal achieved 62% of total nitrogen removal and 97% of total phosphorous removal, when applying C. sorokiniana in the batch systems with hydraulic retention time of 9 days.

The growth potential and the nutrient removal capacity of C. sorokiniana in a continuous laboratory-scale photobioreactor were also investigated. The system removed total nitrogen and total phosphorous by approximately 17% and 27%, respectively, with hydraulic retention time of 5.5 days. High ammonium removal yet high nitrate release indicated microalgae-nitrifiers imbalance in the photobioreactor system. Unfavorable growth factor for microalgae in the photobioreactor could be carbon-limited media in wastewater (2C:22N:1P). Adding an external source of CO2 to control alkalinity, pH, and provide carbon source for microalgal growth is most probably needed for further investigation. Even though nutrient removal efficiencies in continuous photobioreactor were significantly lower than the batch test, biomass yield in the photobioreactor was higher (0.16±0.02 gTNremoved∙gSS-1 and 0.03±0.005 gTPremoved∙gSS-1), compared to the batch test (0.04±0.01 gTNremoved∙gSS-1 and 0.02±0.002 gTPremoved∙gSS-1). High biomass production suggested that microalgal-based treatment for UASB effluent could offer a resource recovery potential.

Overall, this study demonstrated the feasibility of UASB system treating municipal wastewater at low-temperatures and variable loadings in a long-term application. In combination with suitable post-treatments, UASB system showed a viable secondary pre-treatment option unit process for achieving lower carbon footprint wastewater treatment and resource recovery at low-temperatures. The robustness exhibited to low-temperature and variable loading conditions provides a solid basis for further research and potential applications. Further advances in an integrated UASB system and post-treatment unit processes investigation will be needed for pilot- and/or full-scale applications in the future.

Author Biography

Anissa Sukma Safitri

Research assistant
Faculty of Science and Technology
Department of Chemistry, Bioscience and Environmental Engineering
University of Stavanger


Aiyuk, Sunny, Joyce Amoako, Lutgarde Raskin, Adrianus van Haandel, and Willy Verstraete. 2004. "Removal of Carbon and Nutrients from Domestic Wastewater Using a Low Investment, Integrated Treatment Concept." Water Research 38 (13): 3031-42.

Akila, G., and T.S. Chandra. 2007. "Performance of an UASB Reactor Treating Synthetic Wastewater at Low-Temperature Using Cold-Adapted Seed Slurry." Process Biochemistry 42 (3): 466-71.

Bandara, Wasala M.K.R.T.W., Tomonori Kindaichi, Hisashi Satoh, Manabu Sasakawa, Yoshihito Nakahara, Masahiro Takahashi, and Satoshi Okabe. 2012. "Anaerobic Treatment of Municipal Wastewater at Ambient Temperature: Analysis of Archaeal Community Structure and Recovery of Dissolved Methane." Water Research 46 (17): 5756-64.

Bowen, Emma J., Jan Dolfing, Russell J. Davenport, Fiona L. Read, and Thomas P. Curtis. 2014. "Low-Temperature Limitation of Bioreactor Sludge in Anaerobic Treatment of Domestic Wastewater." Water Science and Technology 69 (5): 1004.

Cardinali-Rezende, Juliana, Juliana C. Araújo, Paulo G. S. Almeida, Carlos A. L. Chernicharo, José L. Sanz, Edmar Chartone-Souza, and Andréa M. A. Nascimento. 2013. "Organic Loading Rate and Food-to-Microorganism Ratio Shape Prokaryotic Diversity in a Demo-Scale up-Flow Anaerobic Sludge Blanket Reactor Treating Domestic Wastewater." Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 104 (6): 993-1003.

Chernicharo, C. A. L. 2006. "Post-Treatment Options for the Anaerobic Treatment of Domestic Wastewater." Reviews in Environmental Science and Bio/Technology 5 (1): 73-92.

Collins, Gavin, Sharon McHugh, Sean Connaughton, Anne-Marie Enright, Aileen Kearney, Colm Scully, Thérèse Mahony, Paádhraig Madden, and Vincent O'Flaherty. 2006. "New Low-Temperature Applications of Anaerobic Wastewater Treatment." Journal of Environmental Science and Health, Part A 41 (5): 881-95.

Dague, Richard R., Gouranga C. Banik, and Timothy G. Ellis. 1998. "Anaerobic Sequencing Batch Reactor Treatment of Dilute Wastewater at Psychrophilic Temperatures." Water Environment Research 70 (2): 155-60.

De Vrieze, Jo, Tom Hennebel, Nico Boon, and Willy Verstraete. 2012. "Methanosarcina: The Rediscovered Methanogen for Heavy Duty Biomethanation." Bioresource Technology 112 (May): 1-9.

Earl, J., G. Hall, R. W. Pickup, D. A. Ritchie, and C. Edwards. 2003. "Analysis of Methanogen Diversity in a Hypereutrophic Lake Using PCR-RFLP Analysis of Mcr Sequences." Microbial Ecology 46 (2): 270-78.

Elmitwalli, Tarek A., Kim L.T. Oahn, Grietje Zeeman, and Gatze Lettinga. 2002. "Treatment of Domestic Sewage in a Two-Step Anaerobic Filter/Anaerobic Hybrid System at Low-temperature." Water Research 36 (9): 2225-32.

Elmitwalli, Tarek, and Ralf Otterpohl. 2011. "Grey Water Treatment in Upflow Anaerobic Sludge Blanket (UASB) Reactor at Different Temperatures." Water Science and Technology 64 (3): 610-17.

Großkopf Regine, Stubner Stephan, and Liesack Werner. 1998. "Novel Euryarchaeotal Lineages Detected on Rice Roots and in the Anoxic Bulk Soil of Flooded Rice Microcosms." Applied and Environmental Microbiology 64 (12): 4983-89.

Henze, M., M. C. M. van Loosdrecht, G.A. Ekama, and D. Brdjanovic. 2008. Biological Wastewater Treatment: Principles, Modelling and Design. IWA Publishing.

Høj, Lone, Rolf A Olsen, and Vigdis L Torsvik. 2008. "Effects of Temperature on the Diversity and Community Structure of Known Methanogenic Groups and Other Archaea in High Arctic Peat." The ISME Journal 2 (1): 37-48.

Huser, Beat A., Karl Wuhrmann, and Alexander J. B. Zehnder. 1982. "Methanothrix Soehngenii Gen. Nov. Sp. Nov., a New Acetotrophic Non-Hydrogen-Oxidizing Methane Bacterium." Archives of Microbiology 132 (1): 1-9.

Kettunen, R. H., and J. A. Rintala. 1997. "The Effect of Low-temperature (5-29 °C) and Adaptation on the Methanogenic Activity of Biomass." Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology 48 (4): 570-76.

Kettunen, Riitta H., and Jukka A. Rintala. 1998. "Performance of an On-Site UASB Reactor Treating Leachate at Low-temperature." Water Research 32 (3): 537-46.

Koster, I. W., and G. Lettinga. 1985. "Application of the Upflow Anaerobic Sludge Bed (UASB) Process for Treatment of Complex Wastewaters at Low-temperatures." Biotechnology and Bioengineering 27 (10): 1411-17.

Kotsyurbenko, O. R., A. N. Nozhevnikova, T. I. Soloviova, and G. A. Zavarzin. 1996. "Methanogenesis at Low-temperatures by Microflora of Tundra Wetland Soil." Antonie van Leeuwenhoek 69 (1): 75-86.

Kotsyurbenko, Oleg R., Michail V. Glagolev, Alla N. Nozhevnikova, and Ralf Conrad. 2001. "Competition between Homoacetogenic Bacteria and Methanogenic Archaea for Hydrogen at Low-temperature." FEMS Microbiology Ecology 38 (2-3): 153-59.

Kwon, Min Jung, Ji Young Jung, Binu M. Tripathi, Mathias Göckede, Yoo Kyung Lee, and Mincheol Kim. 2019. "Dynamics of Microbial Communities and CO2 and CH4 Fluxes in the Tundra Ecosystems of the Changing Arctic." Journal of Microbiology 57 (5): 325-36.

Lettinga, G., J. B. van Lier, J. C.L. van Buuren, and G.. Zeeman. 2001. "Sustainable Development in Pollution Control and the Role of Anaerobic Treatment." Water Science and Technology 44 (6): 181-88.

Lettinga, G., A. F. M. van Velsen, S. W. Hobma, W. de Zeeuw, and A. Klapwijk. 1980. "Use of the Upflow Sludge Blanket (USB) Reactor Concept for Biological Wastewater Treatment, Especially for Anaerobic Treatment." Biotechnology and Bioengineering 22 (4): 699-734.

Lettinga, Gatze, Salih Rebac, and Grietje Zeeman. 2001. "Challenge of Psychrophilic Anaerobic Wastewater Treatment." Trends in Biotechnology 19 (9): 363-70.

Li, Weizhong, Limin Fu, Beifang Niu, Sitao Wu, and John Wooley. 2012. "Ultrafast Clustering Algorithms for Metagenomic Sequence Analysis." Briefings in Bioinformatics 13 (6): 656-68.

Liu, Yuchen, and William B. Whitman. 2008. "Metabolic, Phylogenetic, and Ecological Diversity of the Methanogenic Archaea." Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences 1125 (1): 171-89.

Liu, Ze-hua, Hua Yin, Zhi Dang, and Yu Liu. 2014. "Dissolved Methane: A Hurdle for Anaerobic Treatment of Municipal Wastewater." Environmental Science & Technology 48 (2): 889-90.

Ma, Kai, Xiaoli Liu, and Xiuzhu Dong. 2005. "Methanobacterium Beijingense Sp. Nov., a Novel Methanogen Isolated from Anaerobic Digesters." International Journal of Systematic and Evolutionary Microbiology. Microbiology Society.

Magoč, Tanja, and Steven L Salzberg. 2011. "FLASH: Fast Length Adjustment of Short Reads to Improve Genome Assemblies." Bioinformatics (Oxford, England) 27 (21): 2957-63.

Mahmoud, Nidal, Grietje Zeeman, Huub Gijzen, and Gatze Lettinga. 2004. "Anaerobic Sewage Treatment in a One-Stage UASB Reactor and a Combined UASB-Digester System." Water Research 38 (9): 2348-58.

Mai, D. T., C. Kunacheva, and D. C. Stuckey. 2018. "A Review of Posttreatment Technologies for Anaerobic Effluents for Discharge and Recycling of Wastewater." Critical Reviews in Environmental Science and Technology 48 (2): 167-209.

McKeown, Rory M., Colm Scully, Thérèse Mahony, Gavin Collins, and Vincent O'Flaherty. 2009. "Long-Term (1243 Days), Low-Temperature (4-15°C), Anaerobic Biotreatment of Acidified Wastewaters: Bioprocess Performance and Physiological Characteristics." Water Research 43 (6): 1611-20.

McKeown, Rory, Colm Scully, Anne-Marie Enright, Fabio Chinalia, Changsoo Lee, Thérèse Mahony, Gavin Collins, and Vincent O'Flaherty. 2009. "Psychrophilic Methanogenic Community Development during Long-Term Cultivation of Anaerobic Granular Biofilms." The ISME Journal 3 (11): 1231-42.

Moosbrugger, R. E., M. C. Wentzel, G. A. Ekama, and G. v. R. Marais. 1993. "A 5 PH Point Titration Method for Determining the Carbonate and SCFA Weak Acid/Bases in Anaerobic Systems." Water Science and Technology 28 (2): 237-45.

Nordgård, Anna Synnøve Røstad, Wenche Hennie Bergland, Olav Vadstein, Vladimir Mironov, Rune Bakke, Kjetill Østgaard, and Ingrid Bakke. 2017. "Anaerobic Digestion of Pig Manure Supernatant at High Ammonia Concentrations Characterized by High Abundances of Methanosaeta and Non-Euryarchaeotal Archaea." Scientific Reports 7 (1): 15077.

Nozhevnikova, Alla N., Valeria Nekrasova, Adrian Ammann, Alexander J.B. Zehnder, Bernhard Wehrli, and Christof Holliger. 2007. "Influence of Temperature and High Acetate Concentrations on Methanogenensis in Lake Sediment Slurries." FEMS Microbiology Ecology 62 (3): 336-44.

Oren, Aharon. 2014. "The Family Methanocorpusculaceae." In The Prokaryotes: Other Major Lineages of Bacteria and The Archaea, edited by Eugene Rosenberg, Edward F. DeLong, Stephen Lory, Erko Stackebrandt, and Fabiano Thompson, 225-30. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg.

Owusu-Agyeman, Isaac, Özge Eyice, Zeynep Cetecioglu, and Elzbieta Plaza. 2019. "The Study of Structure of Anaerobic Granules and Methane Producing Pathways of Pilot-Scale UASB Reactors Treating Municipal Wastewater under Sub-Mesophilic Conditions." Bioresource Technology 290 (October): 121733.

Petropoulos, Evangelos, Jan Dolfing, Russell J. Davenport, Emma J. Bowen, and Thomas P. Curtis. 2017. "Developing Cold-Adapted Biomass for the Anaerobic Treatment of Domestic Wastewater at Low-temperatures (4, 8 and 15 °C) with Inocula from Cold Environments." Water Research 112 (April): 100-109.

Petropoulos, Evangelos, Burhan Shamurad, Shamas Tabraiz, Yongjie Yu, Russell Davenport, Thomas P. Curtis, and Jan Dolfing. 2021. "Sewage Treatment at 4 °C in Anaerobic Upflow Reactors with and without a Membrane - Performance, Function and Microbial Diversity." Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology 7 (1): 156-71.

Rebac, S., J.B. van Lier, P. Lens, A.J.M. Stams, F. Dekkers, K.Th.M. Swinkels, and G. Lettinga. 1999. Psychrophilic Anaerobic Treatment of Low Strength Wastewaters. Vol. 39. Water Science and Technology.

Rebac, Salih, Julia Ruskova, Sybren Gerbens, Jules B. van Lier, Alfons J.M. Stams, and Gatze Lettinga. 1995. "High-Rate Anaerobic Treatment of Wastewater under Psychrophilic Conditions." Journal of Fermentation and Bioengineering 80 (5): 499-506.

Rosa, A.P., C.A.L. Chernicharo, L.C.S. Lobato, R.V. Silva, R.F. Padilha, and J.M. Borges. 2018. "Assessing the Potential of Renewable Energy Sources (Biogas and Sludge) in a Full-Scale UASB-Based Treatment Plant." SI: Waste Biomass to Biofuel 124 (August): 21-26.

Safitri, Anissa Sukma, Roald Kommedal, and Krista M. Kaster. n.d. "Microbial Community Dynamic in Long-Term UASB Reactor Operation Treating Municipal Wastewater at Low-temperatures." In Preparation.

Schellinkhout, A., and C. J. Collazos. 1992. "Full-Scale Application of the UASB Technology for Sewage Treatment." Water Science and Technology 25 (7): 159-66.

Seghezzo, Lucas, Grietje Zeeman, Jules B. van Lier, H.V.M. Hamelers, and Gatze Lettinga. 1998. "A Review: The Anaerobic Treatment of Sewage in UASB and EGSB Reactors." Bioresource Technology 65 (3): 175-90.

Show, Kuan-Yeow, Yuegen Yan, Haiyong Yao, Hui Guo, Ting Li, De-Yang Show, Jo-Shu Chang, and Duu-Jong Lee. 2020. "Anaerobic Granulation: A Review of Granulation Hypotheses, Bioreactor Designs and Emerging Green Applications." Bioresource Technology 300 (March): 122751.

Silva Martins, Alessandra da, Bernardo Ornelas Ferreira, Nirvana Cecília Ribeiro, Raiane Martins, Laura Rabelo Leite, Guilherme Oliveira, Luis Felipe Colturato, Carlos Augusto Chernicharo, and Juliana Calabria de Araujo. 2017. "Metagenomic Analysis and Performance of a Mesophilic Anaerobic Reactor Treating Food Waste at Various Load Rates." Environmental Technology 38 (17): 2153-63.

Singh, Kripa Shankar, Hideki Harada, and T. Viraraghavan. 1996. "Low-Strength Wastewater Treatment by a UASB Reactor." Bioresource Technology 55 (3): 187-94.

Singh, Suniti, B. Conall Holohan, Simon Mills, Juan Castilla-Archilla, Marika Kokko, Jukka Rintala, Piet N. L. Lens, Gavin Collins, and Vincent O'Flaherty. 2020. "Enhanced Methanization of Long-Chain Fatty Acid Wastewater at 20°C in the Novel Dynamic Sludge Chamber-Fixed Film Bioreactor." Frontiers in Energy Research 8: 166.

Singh, Suniti, Johanna M. Rinta-Kanto, Riitta Kettunen, Henrik Tolvanen, Piet Lens, Gavin Collins, Marika Kokko, and Jukka Rintala. 2019. "Anaerobic Treatment of LCFA-Containing Synthetic Dairy Wastewater at 20 °C: Process Performance and Microbial Community Dynamics." Science of The Total Environment 691 (November): 960-68.

Smith, A. L., S. J. Skerlos, and L. Raskin. 2015. "Anaerobic Membrane Bioreactor Treatment of Domestic Wastewater at Psychrophilic Temperatures Ranging from 15 °C to 3 °C." Environmental Science: Water Research & Technology 1 (1): 56-64.

Smith, Adam L., Steven J. Skerlos, and Lutgarde Raskin. 2012. "Psychrophilic Anaerobic Membrane Bioreactor Treatment of Domestic Wastewater." Water Research.

Söllinger, Andrea, and Tim Urich. 2019. "Methylotrophic Methanogens Everywhere - Physiology and Ecology of Novel Players in Global Methane Cycling." Biochemical Society Transactions 47 (6): 1895-1907.

Souza, C. L., C. A. L. Chernicharo, and S. F. Aquino. 2011. "Quantification of Dissolved Methane in UASB Reactors Treating Domestic Wastewater under Different Operating Conditions." Water Science and Technology 64 (11): 2259-64.

Varsadiya, Milan, Tim Urich, Gustaf Hugelius, and Jiří Bárta. 2021. "Microbiome Structure and Functional Potential in Permafrost Soils of the Western Canadian Arctic." FEMS Microbiology Ecology, no. fiab008 (January).

Wainaina, Steven, Mukesh Kumar Awasthi, Surendra Sarsaiya, Hongyu Chen, Ekta Singh, Aman Kumar, B. Ravindran, et al. 2020. "Resource Recovery and Circular Economy from Organic Solid Waste Using Aerobic and Anaerobic Digestion Technologies." Bioresource Technology 301 (April): 122778.

Wilhelm, Emmerich., Rubin. Battino, and Robert J. Wilcock. 1977. "Low-Pressure Solubility of Gases in Liquid Water." Chemical Reviews 77 (2): 219-62.

Wu, Jing, Zohaib Ur Rehman Afridi, Zhi Ping Cao, Zhong Liang Zhang, Souhila Poncin, Huai Zhi Li, Jian E. Zuo, and Kai Jun Wang. 2016. "Size Effect of Anaerobic Granular Sludge on Biogas Production: A Micro Scale Study." Bioresource Technology 202 (February): 165-71.

Wu, Pei-Hsun, Kok Kwang Ng, Pui-Kwan Andy Hong, Ping-Yi Yang, and Cheng-Fang Lin. 2017. "Treatment of Low-Strength Wastewater at Mesophilic and Psychrophilic Conditions Using Immobilized Anaerobic Biomass." Chemical Engineering Journal 311 (March): 46-54.

Yang, Sizhong, Susanne Liebner, Matthias Winkel, Mashal Alawi, Fabian Horn, Corina Dörfer, Julien Ollivier, et al. 2017. "In-Depth Analysis of Core Methanogenic Communities from High Elevation Permafrost-Affected Wetlands." Soil Biology and Biochemistry 111 (August): 66-77.

Zhang, Lei, Jo de Vrieze, Tim L.G. Hendrickx, Wei Wei, Hardy Temmink, Huub Rijnaarts, and Grietje Zeeman. 2018. "Anaerobic, Treatment of Raw Domestic Wastewater in a UASB-Digester at 10 °C and Microbial Community Dynamics." Chemical Engineering Journal 334 (February): 2088-97.

Zhang, Ying, Xin Wang, Miao Hu, and Pengfei Li. 2015. "Effect of Hydraulic Retention Time (HRT) on the Biodegradation of Trichloroethylene Wastewater and Anaerobic Bacterial Community in the UASB Reactor." Applied Microbiology and Biotechnology 99 (4): 1977-87.
Cover image



May 23, 2022


Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.